Apple Mac OS X vs Microsoft Windows

From WikiVS, the open comparison website
(Redirected from OS X vs Windows)
Jump to: navigation, search


{{Vs|Ma | Logic | | | | yes | no |- | Final Cut | | | | yes | no |- | SoftImage XSI | | | | no | yes |}

Contents

[edit] Security

[edit] Malware

HELOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOon from its open source UNIX heritage. The most critical components of Mac OS X are open for review by a worldwide community of security experts.

Apple Inc. , Get a Mac

Apple touts this feature as an advantage over (pre-Vista) Windows: "On a Windows PC, software (both good and evil) can change the system without your even knowing about it." The latest version of Mac OS X added sandboxing to improve protection against malware and trojans, but it cannot protect against malware that a user installs.

Windows Vista recently started to focus more on security by implementing a stricter user-permission policy (called User Account Control, or UAC), but many users feel that the strict policy is more annoying than useful, resulting in some of these users disabling the feature altogether. Windows 7 has partially reduced those policies attempting to blend security with acceptable Windows user experience.

[edit] Viruses

Windows' large market share has made it a target for hackers creating viruses and other malicious software. Some counts place the number of Windows/MS-DOS viruses at over 50,000. It is critical that Windows users diligently run anti-virus programs and keep them up to date.

Infection of Macs running OS X is extremely rare, and there has never been a large-scale infection of computers running OS X (but the same goes for OpenBSD, FreeBSD, AIX, HP_UX and Linux et al). The same security measures that secures Mac OS X applies to these operating systems - due to OS X's core security being inherited from unix.

[edit] Patches

Both Macs and Windows have patches and/or updates provided online by Apple and Microsoft, respectively.

Through one simple button-click change in the System Preferences this can be on or off, to differing degrees. Ever since the release of Mac OS X 10.1 on September 25, 2001 as a 'free update' to version 10.0, Macs can download these automatically or the [owner or administrator] user has the option of accepting these downloads or not: "New software is available for your computer. If you're not ready to install now, you can use the Software Update preference to check for updates later."

In Windows XP, Vista and Windows7, the user has the option of turning automatic Windows updates on or off. Most major Windows applications install their own update programs which periodically check to see if the particular application is up to date.

[edit] Reliability

People who prefer Mac claim the following:

It just works... all the hardware and software just works, and works well together.

That’s because a Mac offers absolutely flawless integration of hardware and software. Only with a Mac do you get a system built by the same people who make the OS, the applications, and the computer itself.

Mac users who have Windows in their past tend to agree on a simple point: The Macintosh operating system and its custom-tailored hardware make for a far more reliable, less trouble-prone environment than Windows. It's difficult to put a price tag on that advantage, but it's the advantage that I find the most compelling.

IIndependent testing by Consumers Union ConsumberReports.org rated customer tech support highest among OSs - and reduced interferences resulting from 3rd party software conflicts - probably since Apple controls both hardware and software in out-of-the-box purchases raising the quality expectations and user experiences.

"Customer complaints & Issues"

Apple Defects , Apple Defects

New MacBook Pro 15" user had to deal with 7 replacements within 2 months

"The Unofficial Apple Weblog" , Apple's Dwindling Quality

3rd Post- "helped a little bit, but not much... seriously i never thought id want to go back to windows, but its happening!"

Apple suffers under defects just as many times as other companies due [do] but are given a pass when other companies pay dearly for them. Since it is seen as "cream of the crop" despite not having the best in any category.

[edit] Maintenance

[edit] Operating system upgrades

Latest upgrades:

Mavericks 64 bit - Free from App Store. Released 2013

Mountain Lion 64 bit - $19.99 download from App Store. Released 2012

Lion 64 bit - $29.99 download from App Store or ordered on a USB stick. Released 2011

SnowLeopard 64 bit - $29 - Upgrade is done in place and typically takes about 45 minutes. Released 2009

SnowLeopard has brought widespread improvements to the Apple computing platform. It is capable of running as a fully 64 bit operating system on computers which support this. Grand Central Dispatch is available to applications for better use of multiple processor cores and OpenCL allows applications to utilize the power of graphic processors for uses outside of graphics. SnowLeopard is also approximately 7GB smaller than Leopard. Several tweaks have also been made to the interface.

Windows 7 Home Premium 32 bit $119.99 - Upgrade from Vista requires no full install, no backup, however it is (unofficially) recommended to perform a clean install because an in-place upgrade leaves a lot to be desired in terms of stability compared to a clean install. This also applies to Mac OS X.

Windows 7 had many of the same kinds of upgrades over it's predecessor as SnowLeopard did. The performance of Windows 7 was improved substantially as a direct response to consumer disappointment over performance issues of Windows Vista. Steve Ballmer confirmed that 'Windows 7 would be a refined version of Windows Vista' while speaking about Windows 7 on October 16, 2008. [1] There are many who believe that Windows Vista was released prematurely and Windows 7 should have been released as a service pack, rather than a new version of Windows for purchase.

Every other release of Windows is a refinement of the earlier based on kernel version numbers. For example Windows 2000 was 5.0 while Windows XP was 5.1. Vista was 6.0 and 7 was 6.1. Mac OS X has major revisions every few years with many changes under the hood, except for Snow Leopard, which was a "refinement" release. Mac OS X also has minor updates with bug fixes and added features. The version numbers are as follows, 10.x.y, where "x" is the major release and "y" is the minor release. Contrary to popular belief, 10 is NOT the major release number, it is simply part of the operating system's name, which is Mac OS X (a latin letter "10").

[edit] Backup / Restore

Mac OS X - TimeMachine - Automatically or manually backs up system as often as you chose as well as reverting the system back to a specific date and time of your choice. Also cloud based storage and backup services are avail for free as well as a paid upgrade for more storage.

Windows 7 - System Restore can restore the computer to an earlier state, and Backup can automatically backup your system

Windows 8 - File History automatically backs up important files

[edit] Disk Defragmentation

Mac OS X - Disk fragmentation may occur, however the file system is journaled, meaning the chance of fragmentation happening is very unlikely. [2]

Windows - Requires occasional defragmentation with XP or below. Vista and above have defragmentation set to run automatically out of the box.

[edit] Performance

While Mac OS X does have the benefit of faster startup and shutdown in many cases, as well as higher performance in many other areas, an article by CNET editor Dong Ngo suggests that graphics applications may run faster on Windows 7. [3]. This article describes a test in which benchmarking software was run on the same MacBook Pro both in pure (not virtual) Windows 7 and Mac OS X environments. According to Dong "Windows 7 noticeably outdoes Snow Leopard in the 3D image rendering benchmark." It is also noted on Call of Duty 4 that "Snow Leopard was always 5fps to 7fps slower than Windows 7."-Dong. The other areas of this test confirmed the better general performance of Mac OS X. His conclusion was that Windows 7 may be a better choice for gamers. [4].

[edit] Philosophies

[edit] Freedom

Many Linux users prefer Macs over PCs because of the Mac's UNIX architecture. There are many projects (DarwinPorts, MacPorts, and Fink) focused on compiling popular open source applications for Mac OS X that usually run on Linux.

The kernel of Mac OS X (Darwin, which is responsible for running applications, booting up the computer, and many many other behind the scenes things, and is based off of the BSD kernel), as well as components such as WebKit and CUPS are open source software. The user interface and applications bundled with the system are generally proprietary.

Comparing Apple to Microsoft is almost completely meaningless in this context, because Apple is a company in the hardware business that happens develop and bundle an insanely great—but non-free—OS with their hardware.

Personal tools
Namespaces
Variants
Actions
Navigation
Ads
Toolbox